What does it mean to teach in the 21st Century? With so much technology available to students today, and information readily available at their fingertips, is the job of Teacher becoming obsolete?
With the internet and all that it implies, students can find information on anything, anywhere and anytime; blogs, Facebook, cell phones, Twitter, Wikipedia, YouTube, iPods, and Google; they have access to virtually limitless information. Teachers are no longer the main source of knowledge and students are not ‘empty vessels’ waiting to be filled. The teachers’ role now is to be the filter, to teach students how to handle the vast array of resources, to look at information and technology both critically and creatively and to prepare them for what is to come, in a sense we must teach them to see both the forest AND the trees.
Students today know how to use Google, but think about this, has anyone shown them how to validate, collaborate, corroborate, synthesize and problem solve with information they find there? That, in short, is the job of a teacher in a technology based classroom today. Authors Cher Ping Lim, Meow Sien Pek, and Ching Sing Chai tell us that the main benefits of using technology in the classroom is the development of higher order thinking skills and collaborative learning. To add to this idea, technology in the classroom enhances learning by providing differentiated instruction, higher order thinking and learning, for the most part uses no papers or allergens and teaches to the multiple intelligences; everything that an education student is being taught to consider and implement in their teaching practice today.
In the article, Classroom Management Issues in ICT, the authors state that, “Currently, all lessons are conducted in the physical classroom—with the advancement of technology, students no longer need to be in the classroom physically; they may be learning in a virtual classroom.” With this reality looming before us, it is that much more important that we teach critical thinking to our students now, while we have them in front of us; waiting until they are away from us in a virtual world, may be too late.
Authors Rupert Wegerif and Lyn Dawes examine the notion of thinking and learning with ICT by examining ‘The Classroom of the Future’ by Bridget Cooper. “Miss Cooper’s focus on technology was tempered by recognition of the importance of the emotional experience in learning. Children, she insisted, need to feel secure and valued if they are to be able to take risks and be creative.” This blogger would add that along with the security to take risks, it is important for teachers to instil a passion and awareness in students of the significance of what they are learning and how they are learning it. ICT moves students work and ideas outside of the classroom, the filing cabinet the shoebox under the bed, into the real world. In his lecture on ICT across the curriculum, John Finch from the Government of Manitoba department of Education told a story that illustrates the example perfectly; as a teacher Finch had a very bright student, who was also a very lazy student. It was in the early days of the Internet, or the world wide web, and Finch suggested to the boy that he write a short piece on his favourite band Green Day, and publish it on the Internet. The boy complied, but with a very shoddy piece of writing, full of poorly researched information and riddled with spelling mistakes. Sometime later Finch received an email from none other than Green Day’s manager. The band had been searching the web for articles written about them and found the boys piece. They wanted to correct a few facts he had gotten wrong, but most importantly, and what struck a chord so loudly was, Green Day wanted to know why a boy in grade 5 could not spell the following words, and they provided a list. The boy immediately told Finch he MUST re write and re submit the piece, which he did of course, writing a far superior piece the second time. In this case, technology provided a global audience for a student, who until then could not see the point in creating superior work that would never be shared beyond his classroom and teacher.
John Finch recognized the internet as new innovation that was worth keeping up with; our job is to teach students how to evaluate what technologies are useful to them, analyze how to best use those technologies, understand all implications both positive and negative, apply the knowledge and finally, create. The question in the 21st century classroom is, what does creation really mean today? In the world of technology it means: blogging, podcasting, animating, planning, recording, designing and programming for starters. In order to access these modes of creation students need skills, they must understand words such as, subscribe, edit, twitter, tweet, reflect, comment, tag, search, locate, network, post, link, bookmark and upload. Once teachers have shared the tools for creation and skills that accompany them they must next make students understand that in a high speed world where everything they need to know is a button click away that they must proceed with responsibility and integrity. Students need to be cognisant of the meaning of words such as plagiarism, copyright, pirating, slander and confidentiality; in short after acquiring the knowledge and skills required to create with technology, they must acquire the attitude of professionalism. Once again we see the role of the teacher in the 21st century, not only is the teacher not obsolete, but in fact more vital and more dynamic than ever before!
Teachers who fear technology in the classroom question how they will manage laptops, cell phones and iPods at school. The answer is simply the same way you manage students who are using paper, pencils and textbooks. Good classroom management, learning objectives that are specific but flexible and clear guidelines and expectations are key to seamlessly integrating technology into the classroom. According to Howard Pitler et al, in the article ‘Using Technology with Classroom Instruction that Works’ “Research shows that when students are allowed to set some of their own learning goals, their motivation is higher and their behaviour is better, than when they pursue only teacher-set goals”. Not only that, but teachers must also come to understand that these new technological tools may provide temptation, but ultimately they are not the source of negative behaviour. Lessons that are relevant and engaging start with the teacher, secondary to that are the tools the teachers choose to create stimulating lessons. Teachers in the 21st century can provide meaningful and powerful engagement on a level not available to teachers before 1990. It is our job to use whatever tools necessary to make great learning occur. Teachers need to research, collaborate, take risks and not be afraid to teach 21st century skills.
In the 21st century no matter what content, skills or subjects we teach, the question a teacher must ask is what does it mean NOW to teach? Are we using all of the tools provided, without fear, to our and our students’ best advantage? Are we teaching our students to see the trees, and then create the forest?
"This blogger would add that along with the security to take risks, it is important for teachers to instil a passion and awareness in students of the significance of what they are learning and how they are learning it." I think this is probably the hardest part of teaching. When you're confronted with the inevitable question "Why do we have to know this anyways?" it's easier to just say "Because." Being able to articulate a satisfying answer to that question, or better yet, heading off the question from the start, is key to proving to students that what we teach, and what we hope they learn, is meaningful and valuable.
ReplyDeleteAs you point out, Finch's Greenday example shows that technology can help us to achieve this. Technology can extend the classroom outwards to broader audiences in ways that encourage our students to become passionate about engaging in, and publicly demonstrating, learning. We discussed this in Michelle's class when designing end-of-unit exhibits/presentations and I think the same holds true here.
I agree with you Barb, I don't believe that the role of a teacher will become obsolete. As we teach in the 21st century we truly do need to keep in mind that we are not the knowledge givers and they (the students) are not the empty vessels, as you mentioned. Teaching is dynamic, not only are we changing daily but we also need to be changing on a grader scale, to accomodate the needs of the students. Right now the needs of the students are "how do you navigate through this technology?" You said that we need to teach them to "proceed with responsibility and integrity", and you are right. At this, the begining of the technological age our students need us to be master navigators of technology. More than likely in twenty years from now a teacher candidate will be pondering the same questions when they encounter the newsest trend in teaching... How do I teach them to see the trees and create the forest. It is an evolution. You are on the right path.
ReplyDeleteI somewhat have to disagree with a portion of your blog, while simultaneously understanding every single sentence you wrote.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I do not think that teachers will become obsolete, or that our role will change to that of someone ONLY who teaches students media literacy and teaches how to filter out their Google results for relevancy.
I personally think that those Google results wouldn't have been searched for if it weren't for a teacher who sent the students on their way to that information. Teachers are the catalyst for a Wikipedia search. A simple lesson on World Wars sparked a tangent of the Christmas Armstice in my practicum, whereupon the students spent half an hour researching that event and following the links to other interesting war stories. I highly doubt the entire student body would have been as engaged in the World Wars so quickly had I not pointed out this unique situation, nor would many of them found an appealing link to a wiki on that particular subject. Teachers are not going to be obsolete, they're just changing their role to people who facilitate safe internet use, and also provide students with topics of interest to explore further!
I loved your blog, especially the part about Miss Cooper. I think a lot of people who are fearful of the internet are forgetful that it too can be used as a tool to meet Maslow's hierarchy. Having technology in the classroom provides the support network of peers and a guiding teacher to make sure that their needs are met and they are able to grow.
Great use of John Finch as well... I really enjoyed that you re-stated his example of the Green Day letter. That was probably the biggest (but not only) thing that resonated from his presentation. Technology makes things so accessible to students that, in my opinion, the positives outweigh the negatives when technology is used properly and guidance is provided.
Just for the record, I do not think teachers are becoming obsolete at all, quite the opposite
ReplyDeleteIN fact, teachers are more important than ever before and my point is not that we are just filters and Google monitors, but mentors, experts (in some cases) and TEACHERS in the very true sense of the word
ReplyDelete